by vinnie » Fri Sep 18, 2009 7:25 pm
First of all can I please correct a false statement here - "I would like to show a dog that has not been changed dramatically by the Breed Standards". In most breeds, the Standard has not been changed, often for many years. What has changed is popular interpretation of the original Standards. In the UK, most judges are breeders first. And as such, they judge according to what they breed and their reading of what's in their Standard. The two are not necessarily the same! And there is no doubt that exaggerations are rife - often to make a dog stand out from the crowd. A classic example would be in my second breed, the Whippet. I was told that 'if I had a small one, I'd be okay at the lesser levels (Open shows etc.) but I'd not do well at Ch.show level because the judge looked at the big ones, and ignored the small ones'. Hence the breed has increased in size in recent years. Likewise with my first breed, which is supposed to be a substantial, heavy boned breed with wrinkle. Hum. So what we get in the ring in recent years here is huge, heavy animals, who can hardly make it round the ring, never mind run a plough. And puppies who have to have their eyelids tacked while they grow into their skin. I am talking about the worst-possible scenario, but it happens. So it's not the Standards!!
As for what breed - nobody on here can possibly tell you what to go for. If you want less competition in the ring, go for a rarer breed with smaller entries. The rest of it depends on your life style, your home-space, the time you have for grooming (long or short coated breed?), and so on. Go to some shows, and get a feel for the breeds being shown. You have identified breeds from two Groups, Gundogs and Terriers. Each is high-energy, but vastly different.
ps In the UK, steps are being taken by the KC, by amendments to the original Standard, which has been mis-interpreted, to bring my main breed back to where it should be - without exaggeration!!